LX Gas Spring Resource

Gas Spring vs Electric Linear Actuator: Which Should You Use?

Gas spring or electric linear actuator? Compare power, positioning, force, cost and maintenance, when to use lockable gas springs, and how to combine both.

Gas springs and electric linear actuators both move lids, beds, tables, hatches, and panels, but they work in completely different ways. A gas spring is a passive, self-contained part that pushes with stored gas pressure. An electric linear actuator is a motor-driven device that moves to a commanded position. Choosing the wrong one adds cost, weight, and complexity, or leaves users fighting the mechanism.

Short answer: use a gas spring when a person moves the part by hand and only needs help lifting and holding it open, with no power, wiring, or controls. Use a lockable gas spring when the part must stop at any position by hand. Use an electric linear actuator when motion must be powered, automated, remote-controlled, or repeated to a precise position. For heavy loads, combining a gas spring with a smaller actuator is often the most efficient design.

How Each One Works

Gas spring. A sealed cylinder filled with pressurised nitrogen and a little oil. The gas pressure pushes the rod out, giving an extension force that counterbalances the weight of a lid or panel. No power or control is needed. See lift gas springs.

Electric linear actuator. An electric motor drives a gearbox and lead screw, which moves a rod in and out. It needs a power supply and a switch or controller, and it holds position when the motor stops.

Gas Spring vs Linear Actuator: Comparison

Factor Gas spring Electric linear actuator
Power None needed Needs electricity, wiring, and control
Motion Assists manual movement Powered movement, push and pull
Positioning Full open or closed (any position with a lockable gas spring) Any position, repeatable, can be automated
Speed Fast, set by user and damping Slower, set by motor and gearing
Force Fixed by gas charge; rises slightly when compressed Set by motor and gearing; constant over stroke
Size and weight Slim and light Larger and heavier for the same force
Noise Silent Motor and gear noise
Duty cycle Continuous manual use Limited by motor heating
Temperature effect Force drops in cold, rises in heat Little effect on force
Maintenance None; replace at end of life Electrical parts, cables, and controls to service
Cost Low Higher (actuator plus control system)
Failure mode Gradual loss of force over time Motor, control, or power failure stops motion

When to Choose a Gas Spring

When to Choose a Lockable Gas Spring

A lockable gas spring sits between the two. It has an internal valve, so the user presses a lever, button, or cable release, moves the part to any position, and lets go to lock it there. No power is needed. Lockable gas springs are widely used for:

When to Choose an Electric Linear Actuator

Combining a Gas Spring With an Actuator

For heavy lids, hatches, and beds, a gas spring can carry most of the weight while a smaller actuator provides the controlled motion. Because the gas spring counterbalances the load, the actuator needs less force, so it can be smaller, quieter, and cheaper, and it draws less power. The gas spring force and actuator force must be sized together so the mechanism does not drift or overload the actuator in either direction.

How to Decide: Quick Checklist

  1. Will a person move the part by hand? Yes: gas spring. No: actuator.
  2. Must it stop at any position? By hand: lockable gas spring. Automatically: actuator.
  3. Is power available and acceptable? If not, use a gas spring or lockable gas spring.
  4. Is the load very heavy? Consider a gas spring plus a smaller actuator.
  5. What is the budget and volume? Gas springs cost far less per unit and need no controls.

Use the gas spring force calculator to estimate the force your mechanism needs, then request a recommendation from LX Gas Spring. LX gas springs have passed a TÜV fatigue test of 180,000 cycles and are covered by a 3-year warranty.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a gas spring replace an electric linear actuator?

Yes, when the part is moved by hand and only needs help lifting and holding. A gas spring needs no power and costs much less. If the part must move on its own or to exact positions, an actuator is still needed.

Can a gas spring hold a position like an actuator?

A standard gas spring holds a lid fully open. A lockable gas spring can hold any position in its stroke when the release is let go, without power.

Why use a gas spring together with an actuator?

The gas spring carries most of the weight, so a smaller, quieter, lower-power actuator can provide the controlled motion. This is common on heavy hatches, beds, and lift mechanisms.

Which lasts longer, a gas spring or a linear actuator?

They wear differently. A gas spring slowly loses force over many cycles and years; LX gas springs have passed a TÜV fatigue test of 180,000 cycles. An actuator has motor, gear, and electrical parts with a limited duty cycle. Life depends on load, cycle rate, and environment for both.

Is a gas spring cheaper than a linear actuator?

Yes. A gas spring is a single passive part with no motor, wiring, or controller, so the unit and system cost are much lower.